Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

December 30, 2023 @8:00PM We've come to this Old Chicago several times. I like the food but haven't always had the best experience with service. Last night we wanted to give it one last chance and I am glad that we did. We decided to sit in the cocktail/bar area and as usual the food was good but this time the service was excellent. Our server, Felicia, went above and beyond my expectations. She not only ensured the accuracy of our order but had a great personality and sense of humor. She kept our table laughing the entire evening. Thank you for restoring our faith in Old Chicago’s! We will come back often and when we do, we’ll be asking for Felicia.

Deep dish Pepperoni/jalapeno. We had to settle for jalapeno because there was No NM Green Chili. Very disappointing. Pizza was good but if ur gona have green chili as an ingredient on ur menu, u should have it available. It's available in NM😁 Good service, good pizza.

Pizza: was pizza Pretzel sticks with beer cheese was delicious Salad: well, salad is salad. I ordered the spaghetti and meatballs. The pasta and sauce was okay. But, the meatballs were completely inedible. They were burnt, I couldn’t bite into them because they were hard as a rock. Honestly, there are better places to eat, that is better on your wallet!

Stopped in for some beers and pizza, our waitress Ashly was truly the best! So thankful for her knowledge and attentiveness to our needs! The appetizers and pizza were beyond good! Most definitely recommend the rolls! 🤤

Love Old Chicago. Love their pizza.. Great food and libations. The Loveland location is awesome. No comparison with the Thornton location.